Wednesday, December 17, 2014

Book Banning Argument Essay

Devon Forrester

Ms. Galang

ELA Class 810

 

   Paranormal visions, alcohol abuse, strong language and a ghostly apparition named Tony. These can be found within Stephen King's The Shining. Throughout the book, Jack encounters many paranormal things while working as a winter caretaker at the Overlook Hotel. This book should be banned because of alcohol abuse as well as strong language. While the book does contain some positive messages, the negative themes are far more apparent than the positive themes.These themes are especially noticeable in the beginning and middle of the book and are considered inappropriate for young readers.

  The theme of alcohol is very prevalent throughout the book. As a result of this theme, the book has been received quite negatively in the eyes of teachers and librarians. One scene from the book that really shows this theme is when Jack and his drinking partner, Albert Shockley, hit a cyclist while driving home drunk. "...Then the jingling crashing sound as they hit the bike at forty, and it had flown up like a bent and twisted bird, the handlebars striking the windshield, and then it was in the air again, leaving the started safety glass in front of Jack's bulging eyes," (King 37). This quote shows that as Jack and Albert rounded a corner, they hit a cyclist while driving home. Another quote to support the theme of alcohol in this book would be "They were both very drunk; the martians had landed that night in force," (King 36). This quote really reinforces the fact that Jack and Albert were both drunk, as throughout the book, martians is used as a euphemism for martinis.

   In addition to alcohol abuse, another controversial theme found in the book is strong language. Because this kind of language can be found on nearly every page, this is a definite reason for the book to be banned. For example, Jack says "There isn't a Seven-Eleven around here, would you believe it? And I thought they had Seven-Elevens on the f-cking moon" (King 238). Because of the objectionable content found in the book, librarians and teachers may be hesitant to have this book available.   Furthermore, earlier on in the book Jack says "That was crazy. Seventeenth-Century bullish-t" (King 135) when he realises that some wasps he had frozen came back again. These quotes really prove that language is a very strong theme in this book.

  Some may say that one positive theme mentioned in the book is bravery. Because of Jack's sudden change, Danny is forced to become very brave in order to get through the night. For example, Danny stands up to his father and says he isn't afraid of him when he becomes insane. This shows that Danny is forced to grow up within a small amount of time. Furthermore, according to "In Defense of Book Banning," this quote, "To say that knowledge never hurts is to deny that books have any power to influence people at all. And if you're not trying to influence people, why write?" shows that books have to have a message to them. Because of this quote, many of the themes of the book are negative and highly outnumber the amount of positive messages in the book. According to "Darkness too Visible," an article by Meghan Cox Gurdon, "...But the calculus that many parents make is less crude than that: It has to do with a child's happiness, moral development and tenderness of heart. Entertainment dogs not merely gratify taste, after all, but creates it." If younger children were to read this, it could make them more likely to be attracted towards more negative themes, and make them think negatively.

  In conclusion, The Shining should be banned from schools and libraries because of it's alcohol abuse and strong language that are very noticeable in the book. Instead of a full on ban, the best thing to do would be to limit the access of this book to high school students and above. Because drunk driving is a common cause for many accidents, the message that the drunk driving scene attempts to convey is positive but is negative as well.

 

 

 Works Cited

King, Stephen. The Shining. New York: Doubleday, 1977.

"In Defense of Book Banning." Culture. 3 November 2014. <http://federalist.com/2014/03/11/in-defense-of-book-banning/>

"Darkness too visible." Meghan Cox Gurdon. 4 June 2011. <http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303657404576357>.

  

Thursday, December 11, 2014

Argument Essay Draft 1

Devon Forrester

Ms. Galang

ELA Class 810

 

   Paranormal visions, alcohol abuse, strong language and a ghostly apparition named Tony. These can be found within Stephen King's The Shining. Throughout the book, Jack encounters many paranormal things while working as a winter caretaker at the Overlook Hotel. This book should be banned because of alcohol abuse as well as strong language. These themes are especially noticeable in the beginning and middle of the book and are considered inappropriate for young readers.

  The theme of alcohol is very prevalent throughout the book. As a result of this theme, the book has been received quite negatively in the eyes of teachers and librarians. One scene from the book that really shows this theme is when Jack and his drinking partner, Albert Shockley, hit a cyclist while driving home drunk. "...Then the jingling crashing sound as they hit the bike at forty, and it had flown up like a bent and twisted bird, the handlebars striking the windshield, and then it was in the air again, leaving the started safety glass in front of Jack's bulging eyes" (King 37). This quote shows that as Jack and Albert rounded a corner, they hit a cyclist while driving home. Another quote to support the theme of alcohol in this book would be "They were both very drunk; the martians had landed that night in force" (King 36). This quote really reinforces the fact that Jack and Albert were both drunk, as throughout the book, martians is used as a euphemism for martinis.

  Another controversial theme from the book would be strong language. Because this kind of language can be found on nearly every page, this is a definite reason for the book to be banned. For example, Jack says "There isn't a Seven-Eleven around here, would you believe it? And I thought they had Seven-Elevens on the f-cking moon" (King 238). Because of the objectionable content found in the book like librarians and teachers may be hesitant to have this book available. Furthermore, earlier on in the book Jack says "That was crazy. Seventeenth-Century bullish-t" (King 135) when he realises that some wasps he had frozen came back again. These quotes really prove that language is a very strong theme in this book.

  In conclusion, The Shining should be banned from schools and libraries because of it's alcohol abuse and strong language that are very noticeable in the book. Instead of a full on ban, the best thing to do would be to limit the access of this book to high school students and above. Because drunk driving is a common cause for many accidents, the message that the drunk driving scene shows is positive but is negative as well

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Social Awareness Project

Devon Forrester
Class 810
    ELA Social Awareness Project

   Writings included in this packet :
  • Original poem responding to stop and frisk
  • Interview with a pre kindergarten teacher
  • Reading response about some social issues in "The Shining" by Stephen King
        

 

   In this packet, you will find several pieces of literature pertaining to modern day social issues. Among these, you will find an exclusive with a universal pre kindergarten teacher. Also, there is a reading response to Stephen King's "The Shining", but more specifically about the social issues in the book. There is also an original poem included in this packet as well as a brief summary of it.







   Original Poem
     Stop and frisk,
Why take the risk?
You'll never know who you're checking
Until you're being he heckled
Through the ranks you'll be trekking
With embarrassment you'll be freckled
What are these "field inquiries"?
It feels all miry, one wrong step and you're stuck.
If you check the wrong person
you may end up dead,
So why make such a bold move,
by moving ahead?


 The problem this poem was written about is stop and frisk. Although this problem isn't widely broadcasted anymore on the news, this is still very apparent in New York City. The process I went through to write this poem was quite simple. Besides the rhymes, I had an easy time creating the poem. Furthermore, I believe that this poem shows that my opinion is quite negative regarding stop and frisk.


Interview with Aimee Ortiz (my mother)
 -What is your job?
I am a universal pre kindergarten teacher's assistant.
 -How does your job benefit society?
I assist in the process of educating children from a young age
 -If you could change a law pertaining to your job, what would it be?
Because the DOE makes the decisions for the pre kindergarten at my school, I  would like to be able to teach all of my students in a larger group as opposed to small groups, because I believe students learn better in large groups, as they are able to listen to other children's opinions, comments and questions.
 -What's your favorite part of this job?
Watching the children develop and really understand what I teach them.










     Social Issues Reading Response for "The Shining" by Stephen King
     In Stephen King's "The Shining", there are many social issues that are hinted at. For example, the main character, Jack is a recovering alcoholic with a dark past. As a result of this Jack makes many poor decisions early in his life. I would like to focus on Jack's alcohol problem.
 In "The Shining", alcohol is shown as a very negative thing. For example, Jack does many things that came close to murder. One quote to support this would be when he hits a bike while driving home drunk with a friend of his. Jack only realizes that he hit someone after the bike had gone up the windshield of the car. As a result of this and many more incidents, Jack later becomes sober, but is then forced to return to his comfort of alcohol.
 This makes me think that alcohol is a very bad thing, and makes me want to avoid it at all costs. What makes me think this even more, is when Jack’s old memories come back to haunt him. For example, Jack is reminded multiple times about when he broke Danny’s arm out of frustration while he was an alcoholic. Because of this, I don’t want to become unnecessarily violent and inflict harm on others. This book really makes Jack seem to be a negative person when he was an alcoholic and makes me want to steer clear of alcohol when I become older.




Work cited
http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/03/is-stop-and-frisk-worth-it/358644/.

























Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Nonfiction Reading Response


Devon Forrester
Class 810
ELA Nonfiction Reading Response


  The article "To Kill or Not to Kill" by Patricia Smith is about the ongoing argument concerning the death penalty. This article came from an Upfront magazine. The author wants me to know that there have been many changes regarding the death penalty since its institution in the colonial period.
  The author doesn't seem to have any particular bias towards any perspective. To support this, the author includes evidence to support both the for and against perspectives for the ongoing death penalty argument. For example, "Many death penalty supporters interpret the biblical phrase 'an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth' to mean that those who commit murder should meet the same fate." Furthermore, the author includes "opponents say killing is wrong no matter who is doing it, even if it's the government, and that it's too final a punishment in a world where mistakes can happen." This shows that the author doesn't include their opinion, and have kept this article specifically objective.
  The article taught me about the current issues with the United State's death penalty. For example, the text says "...It's become increasingly difficult in recent months for states to get the drugs needed for lethal injection. That's because the European manufacturers refuse to sell them if they're being used for executions." Furthermore, the article also says "Internationally, 98 countries - including all of Europe except for Belarus - have abolished the death penalty." This refusal to sell drugs for lethal injections may be a sign that other countries are disapproving of the choices made by the United States. This shows that the United States may have to change their regulations when it comes to death penalties.
  This text has made me question whether the methods used to carry out executions in most states are correct. Another thing this text has made me question is why other countries have abolished the death penalty. I would like to further research how the  countries that haven't abolished the death penalty have dealt with the death penalty conundrum.

Thursday, November 13, 2014

ELA Trip Blog

Devon Forrester
Class 810
ELA Trip Blog Post

  After the trip to the Museum of the city of New York, I learned a lot of things about social activism in New York City. For example, I learned about one of the earliest forms of social activism, which was a petition signed by Quakers to allow them to practice their religion in public, although Peter Stuyvesant didn't allow them to. Another thing I learned was how women weren't allowed to vote and how there had been a very long fight to allow them to vote. One thing I found to be surprising was how there are still many fights going on about different topics such as the 9/11 memorial, and bike lanes. Learning that these were examples of social activism made me wonder about other current topics that could be considered as social activism.
  Learning that many religions weren't allowed to practice their religion in public in New Amsterdam  during the Colonial period was very surprising. This was shocking to me, because the 1st amendment includes freedom of religion and people were being persecuted in what later becomes the United States. Also, I felt confused when I saw that social activism takes place in the topic of bike lanes, because I have never noticed anything wrong with bike lanes, which makes me want to research further into the topic. One topic I felt strongly about was segregation in New York City. I felt strongly about this, because I had originally thought that the Jim Crow Laws were only for the South, where there was a higher concentration of slaves. In conclusion, the social activism exhibits conveyed a variety of emotions.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

"The Shining" Book Club Reading Response


Devon Forrester Class 810

Insanity, a hotel's dark history and alcohol. All of these things contribute to the eventual mental breakdown of Jack Torrance, the main character of "The Shining".  In the book, "The Shining" by Stephen King I agreed with the current ban on the book. Throughout the book, there are many themes that are most likely the reason why the book was banned. Some of these themes are violence, language, and usage of alcohol.

  One reason why this book is most likely banned is due to its picturesque depiction of violence. Although this is more towards the end of the book, this is probably one of the most likely reasons for the book to be banned. For example, Jack attempts to murder his family while working at the Overlook hotel. A quote to support this would be when Jack is beating his wife, Wendy with a roque mallet, "She heard the mallet whistle through the air and then agony exploded on her right side as the mallet-head took her just below the line of her breasts, breaking two ribs... 'Oh dear God!' She screamed to the Overlook's shadowy lobby, and buried the kitchen knife in [Jack's] lower back up to the handle." This particular scene in the book shows a lot of violence and includes some rather graphic descriptions of wounds inflicted upon Wendy as well as Jack.

   The theme of alcohol is rather prevalent throughout the book. However, it is a few scenes that make alcohol very negative in the book. For example, Jack did many things he regretted because of his alcohol addiction. One thing he had done whilst he was an alcoholic was break his son, Danny's, arm. Another thing he did with a drinking partner of his, Albert Shockley, was hit a bicycle while they were driving home. Later in the book, it turns out that the person riding the bike was a member of Jack's debate team at the school he worked at. A quote from the text to support this would be "[Jack] had whirled Danny around to spank him, his big adult fingers digging into the scant meat of the boy's forearm, meeting around it in a closed fist, and the snap of the breaking bone had not been loud, not loud but it had been very loud, huge, but not loud." This had happened when Jack was still an alcoholic and was the major reason why he had committed to sobriety.
  Another reason why The Shining may be banned is because of the large amounts of strong language that may not be found suitable for a general reading audience. For example, "...And I thought they had Seven-Elevens on the f*cking moon." As a result of this type of language found throughout the book, teachers and librarians may find this book to be inappropriate or be hesitant about having it in their library.
 Some of the reasons why "The Shining" by Stephen King is banned from many public libraries is because of violence, language and usage of alcohol throughout the book. In conclusion, I agreed with the ban on "The Shining" by Stephen King due to high amounts of inappropriate content found throughout the book.



Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Synthesis Page Reading Response (Updated)


Witch and Wizard by James Patterson

Feminist : Wisty
Wisty is a Feminist, because she is one of the main characters, and is Whit's sister. In the book the story is told from two perspectives, Whit and Wisty's.

Reluctant Hero : Whit and Wisty
"Wisteria Allgood," Byron said monotone like a bailiff, and pulled out an actual scroll of official-looking paper. "The New Order is taking you into custody until your trial. You are hereby accused of being a witch." My jaw dropped. "A witch? Are you nuts?" I shrieked. This proves that Wisty doesn't believe that she truly has any sort of special powers, and therefore isn't currently accepting the fact that she's a witch. "As far as I knew, I was not a wizard, and not a superhero either." This quote shows that Whit also doesn't believe that he possesses and special powers as well.

Threshold Guardian : Celia
 " Speaking of which, baby,' Celia said to Whit, it's about time for us to go. We have to risk it...the Shadowland." This quote shows that Celia is a Threshold Guardian for Whit and Wisty, because while they are in prison, she's the one who frees them after they've displayed their magical capability.

Shapeshifter : Byron
"Wisteria Allgood?" As they moved into the light, I saw two men and...Byron Swain? Byron was a kid from my high school, a year older than I, a year younger than Whit. As far as I knew, we both hated his guts. Everyone did." This quote shows that Byron is a shapeshifter, because he goes from being a normal high school student to becoming an interrogator, and imprisoning two of his classmates.

Shadow : The One Who Is The One
"Hello Allgood family," he said in a quiet, forceful tone that made me pay very close attention to every word. "I am The One Who Is The One. Perhaps you've heard of me?"... " I will make this simple for the two of you . All you have to do is renounce your former existence - your freedoms, your way of life, and your parents in particular - and you will be spared. You will not be harmed if you obey the rules. Not a hair on your heads will be touched. I promise. Renounce your former ways and your parents. That's all. Simple as apple pie." This quote shows that The One Who Is The One is truly a menace. Although he currently rules the government, he really is the main antagonist of the story. After all, he has imprisoned many children for reading certain books, listening to music etc.

Stages in the Hero's Journey
The Quest : For Whit and Wisty to save their parents.
The Task : To free them for a New Order prison.
The Journey : Whit and Wisty are imprisoned, freed, and then have to free children from another prison.
Departure : Whit and Wisty are taken prisoner under suspicion of being a wizard and a witch.
Initiation : Whit and Wisty are creed from prison and taken to the Freelands.
Road of Trials : Whit and Wisty have to do an elaborately planned prison break in the middle of enemy territory.
Innermost Cave : Whit and Wisty witness a friend of theirs that fought alongside them be publicity executed for fighting back.
Return and Reintegration with Society : None ( This is the first book of a series )