Devon Forrester
Ms. Galang
ELA Class 810
Paranormal visions, alcohol abuse, strong language and a ghostly apparition named Tony. These can be found within Stephen King's The Shining. Throughout the book, Jack encounters many paranormal things while working as a winter caretaker at the Overlook Hotel. This book should be banned because of alcohol abuse as well as strong language. While the book does contain some positive messages, the negative themes are far more apparent than the positive themes.These themes are especially noticeable in the beginning and middle of the book and are considered inappropriate for young readers.
The theme of alcohol is very prevalent throughout the book. As a result of this theme, the book has been received quite negatively in the eyes of teachers and librarians. One scene from the book that really shows this theme is when Jack and his drinking partner, Albert Shockley, hit a cyclist while driving home drunk. "...Then the jingling crashing sound as they hit the bike at forty, and it had flown up like a bent and twisted bird, the handlebars striking the windshield, and then it was in the air again, leaving the started safety glass in front of Jack's bulging eyes," (King 37). This quote shows that as Jack and Albert rounded a corner, they hit a cyclist while driving home. Another quote to support the theme of alcohol in this book would be "They were both very drunk; the martians had landed that night in force," (King 36). This quote really reinforces the fact that Jack and Albert were both drunk, as throughout the book, martians is used as a euphemism for martinis.
In addition to alcohol abuse, another controversial theme found in the book is strong language. Because this kind of language can be found on nearly every page, this is a definite reason for the book to be banned. For example, Jack says "There isn't a Seven-Eleven around here, would you believe it? And I thought they had Seven-Elevens on the f-cking moon" (King 238). Because of the objectionable content found in the book, librarians and teachers may be hesitant to have this book available. Furthermore, earlier on in the book Jack says "That was crazy. Seventeenth-Century bullish-t" (King 135) when he realises that some wasps he had frozen came back again. These quotes really prove that language is a very strong theme in this book.
Some may say that one positive theme mentioned in the book is bravery. Because of Jack's sudden change, Danny is forced to become very brave in order to get through the night. For example, Danny stands up to his father and says he isn't afraid of him when he becomes insane. This shows that Danny is forced to grow up within a small amount of time. Furthermore, according to "In Defense of Book Banning," this quote, "To say that knowledge never hurts is to deny that books have any power to influence people at all. And if you're not trying to influence people, why write?" shows that books have to have a message to them. Because of this quote, many of the themes of the book are negative and highly outnumber the amount of positive messages in the book. According to "Darkness too Visible," an article by Meghan Cox Gurdon, "...But the calculus that many parents make is less crude than that: It has to do with a child's happiness, moral development and tenderness of heart. Entertainment dogs not merely gratify taste, after all, but creates it." If younger children were to read this, it could make them more likely to be attracted towards more negative themes, and make them think negatively.
In conclusion, The Shining should be banned from schools and libraries because of it's alcohol abuse and strong language that are very noticeable in the book. Instead of a full on ban, the best thing to do would be to limit the access of this book to high school students and above. Because drunk driving is a common cause for many accidents, the message that the drunk driving scene attempts to convey is positive but is negative as well.
Works Cited
King, Stephen. The Shining. New York: Doubleday, 1977.
"In Defense of Book Banning." Culture. 3 November 2014. <http://federalist.com/2014/03/11/in-defense-of-book-banning/>
"Darkness too visible." Meghan Cox Gurdon. 4 June 2011. <http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303657404576357>.